Weight or Weights: What’s Better For Muscle Gain?

Weight or weights

Table of Contents

Confused about bulking up? Weight or weights – which will ramp up your muscle mass faster? Don’t let too heavy a weight slow you down.

Dive into this no-nonsense guide, tailored to help you navigate the weightlifting world. You’re about to learn the secrets to smart lifting, avoiding common mistakes, and maximizing muscle gain.

Strap in, it’s time to get ripped!

key takeaways

  • Weights help muscles grow better than body weight.
  • Bodyweight workouts have movement limitations.
  • Mix weights and body weight for best results.
  • The balance between weight and body weight is key.

Calisthenics vs weights which one should you choose?

Calisthenincs vs weights

In the battle of calisthenics vs weights, it really depends on your personal fitness goals.

For those aiming to build muscle mass and strength quickly, weights are the way to go. They offer the ability to isolate specific muscles and you can continually increase the resistance.

However, if your goal is to enhance overall body control, flexibility, and relative strength while getting a lean, toned physique, calisthenics is an excellent choice. It’s also great for those who prefer home workouts or on-the-go routines without needing a ton of equipment.

Here’s a simplified summary to guide you:

Calisthenics

  • Enhanced Flexibility
  • Increased strength
  • Convenience & Minimal Equipment
  • Overall Lean Physique

Weights

  • Rapid mass
  • Increased strength
  • Body Control
  • Overall Lean Physique

What it Takes to Build Muscle

Muscular man in the gym

So, fellas, here’s the scoop. We’re often stuck at this crossroads, thinking, “Bodyweight workouts or weight lifting for that dream muscle mass?” The answer might surprise you.????

Let’s be honest, hoisting too heavy weight around the gym might give you some instant bravado, but will it fast-track your muscle gain?

Not really…

It’s like trying to finish a marathon without training – chances are, you’ll hit a wall… and it won’t be pretty.

Let’s get real; bodyweight exercises are like old friends – reliable but can sometimes let you down. They’re great, but they have their limits. You’ll eventually hit a plateau where doing a zillion push-ups won’t increase that muscle mass.

Now, let’s talk about weightlifting. It’s like the golden ticket to the muscle mass candy shop. You get to add weights gradually, constantly challenging your muscles. It’s like playing a video game on ‘increasing difficulty’ mode – only it’s your body you’re leveling up! ????

But, don’t toss bodyweight workouts out the window just yet. Mixing them with weightlifting is like combining burgers with beers – a match made in heaven. It ensures you’re getting the best of both worlds.

  • So, what’s the takeaway, gentlemen? Strike a balance between bodyweight exercises and weight lifting for ultimate muscle growth
    Evander Nelson
    Evander Nelson
    NASM CPT Personal Trainer | Menprovement

Body weight Training and Muscle Growth

Bodyweight training

Alright lads, let’s talk about ‘kalos’ and ‘sthenos’, Greek for beauty and strength. No, it’s not a new trendy aftershave; it’s all about bodyweight training or, to use the fancy term, calisthenics.

When you’re pulling off calisthenics, your body is the star of the show, playing the role of both actor and prop. You’re either pulling in or pushing out like a perpetual arm wrestling match against yourself. ????

Take push-ups, the poster child of body weight exercises, classic as a leather jacket and jeans combo. But there’s more to this fitness party than just push-ups.

Turns out, your home is a treasure trove of workout aids. Door frames? Perfect for pull-ups. A sturdy chair? Ideal for step-ups and bench dips. You’ll feel like a DIY gym wizard, just make sure your equipment is as stable as your commitment to fitness.

Door pull up bar

cLICK FOR BEST PRICE

Now, don’t get it twisted. Bodyweight training isn’t primarily about muscle building. If you’re dreaming of looking like a heavyweight champion, you might be barking up the wrong tree. But hey, gymnasts use calisthenics, and they’re not exactly shabby in the muscle department, right? ????

The real deal with bodyweight exercises is boosting strength, flexibility, and speed. Plus, you’ll torch calories faster than you can say “Pass the protein shake”. Especially when you’re doing circuits; those bad boys are the ultimate calorie bonfire! ????

Some folks think bodyweight training is the kiddie pool of fitness, a prelude to the deep end of weights exercises and lifting heavier weights. Well, I say, why not dive into both? There’s room for all in the quest for fitness glory.

There are two problems with bodyweight training when it comes to building muscle.

  • Limited load potential
  • Limited movement ability

Limited Load Potential

Muscular god

Bodyweight training relies on your body weight and gravity to provide resistance. Both of these are limited. After some time, your muscles will no longer be challenged by them. When that happens, the level of stress on the muscle will not be high enough to bring on the adaptation response.

Take the push-up, as an example. A beginner may struggle to pump out a dozen push-ups. Within a month, however, he should be able to rep out with 20 or more of them.

Evander’s note:

The problem here is that the ideal rep range for strength and muscle development is in the 6-30 range. To fully stress the muscle fiber you need high reps, but you also need low reps. The ideal set structure will see you pyramiding from 30 down to six reps over four or five sets.

Now, you might find a set of 30 push-ups a challenge. But you will not find a set of 12, 10, 8, or 6 very challenging. Yet those sets performed to near failure are necessary for muscle growth.

It is possible to add some weight to body weight exercises by wearing a weight vest or putting a weight plate on your back. But this ability is very limited. It is also essentially a conversion of body weight to weight training.

Limited Movement Ability

epic image of a muscular man

Picture it this way: to get a muscle to beef up, it needs to go on a full-on adventure, moving through its complete range of motion while carrying a progressively heavy backpack. Now, it’s tricky to achieve this with bodyweight exercises alone.

Let’s use our latissimus dorsi, or “lats” (y’know, the mighty muscles on your back) as an example. They’re like an intricate highway system sprawling across your back, from your lower spine and ribs, up to your shoulder blade and upper pelvis, and ending at your upper arm bone.

Mostly running diagonally, the lats’ main gig is to pull your arm down towards your hip, following their slanting path. Imagine a one-arm salute moving diagonally to your hip – that’s your lat in action.

When we do chin-ups, the go-to bodyweight exercise for lats, we’re pulling ourselves straight up, not diagonally. See the mismatch? It’s like trying to jam a USB stick in a power socket, ain’t gonna work. ????‍♂️

  • However, here’s the game changer: a cable machine. It’s like having a tailor-made tool for your lats. Perform a single-arm lat pull-in and voila, you’ve got an exercise perfectly mirroring your lat’s natural motion, primed for muscle growth.
    Evander Nelson
    Evander Nelson
    NASM CPT Personal Trainer | Menprovement

This principle applies across the board for every muscle group. If you want to work them to their full potential, you’ll need to lift heavier weights within a specific weight range. Sticking to the same weight just won’t cut it.

Weight Training Benefits for Muscle Growth

Guy doing deadlifts

The million-dollar question, gents: weights or your own weight – which one will beef you up more? Let’s clear the air.

When we revealed the downfalls of bodyweight exercises for muscle build-up, it was like hinting at weight training’s winning hand. It’s like your best mate covering for your blind spots at a party. ✔️

Here’s how it rolls:

  • Initiate your journey with a weight that lets you do 8 reps. By rep 5, it should feel like you’re wrestling a bear and the last two reps? Like moving a mountain.
  • Boost your reps to 12 as your power grows. ????
  • Time to add a pinch more weight and revert back to 8 reps.

Weight lifting lets you guide your muscles through their full workout waltz, loaded and ready. This is particularly true with cable machines, helping you groove the perfect muscle movements, something bodyweight exercises just can’t rival.

Pro Tip:

And if you’re hunting for top-notch dumbbells to upgrade your home gym, I’ve got some tips up my sleeve.

Combining Bodyweight and Weights for Muscle Growth

Two muscular man comoparing abs

You might wonder if bodyweight exercises are for muscle growth as water wings are for deep-sea diving. Absolutely not!

These exercises are the perfect starting blocks for gym rookies, building a foundation of strength and kick-starting muscle development. Plus, they make a mean workout dessert. Picture ending a chest routine with a few push-ups sets to failure.

You’ll feel pumped enough to rip open your shirt, Superman-style! ????‍♂️????

From what we’ve considered so far, you might conclude that bodyweight training is a waste of time for building muscle

Wrapping Up

You’ve journeyed with me from weights to bodyweight and back, unraveled the pros, cons, and muscle-building secrets of each. It’s now your turn to decide your fitness path. Whether you opt for the gym’s gritty iron or bodyweight elegance, remember, the real victory is progress!

Start your transformation today and remember, every rep, every set counts.

FAQs

The three main types of weights include dumbbells, kettlebells, and barbells. Each serves unique functions in strength training and muscle building.

The “best” weight varies greatly on individual strength, fitness level, and workout goals. It should be challenging, but not so heavy that it compromises form.

The “best” weight varies greatly on individual strength, fitness level, and workout goals. It should be challenging, but not so heavy that it compromises form.

As a beginner, women might start with lighter dumbbells, around 2-5 kg. But it’s important to listen to your body and gradually increase as your strength improves.

Did you enjoy this article?

Subscribe to our email list and get updates on the latest self improvement information for men.

Never spam. Always helpful.

Meet The Author:

Subscribe For More
Get the latest self improvement news and the best self improvement content from around the web in one weekly round up.
Table of Contents

The Best Self Improvement Programs For Men..

All In One Place.

menprovement x

Try Menprovemen X. The only self improvement streaming service for men.